When searching for a rental property in Germany, encountering a Mietmakler (rental broker) is common—especially in competitive markets. Understanding their role, legal standing, and associated costs can make or break your rental experience. Here’s a deep dive into Germany’s Mietmakler system.
1. What Is a Mietmakler – and Are They Legal in Germany?
A Mietmakler, or real estate rental broker, acts as an intermediary between landlords and prospective tenants. They assist by:
- Listing rental properties
- Scheduling and conducting viewings
- Facilitating lease agreements
Legally, brokers are allowed—but heavily regulated. Since June 2015, the “Bestellerprinzip”, or “orderer pays” principle, has applied: the person who commissions the broker must foot the bill.
This means:
- If the landlord hires the Mietmakler to find tenants, the landlord pays the commission.
- If the tenant specifically hires the broker to find a property, the tenant pays.
This principle is vital to prevent tenants from being unfairly burdened with broker fees.
2. How Much Do Mietmakler Charges Cost—and Who Pays Them?
Before 2015, tenants commonly paid commissions equal to 2–3 months’ cold rent. Since the reform:
- Landlords typically cover the broker’s fee when renting through a Mietmakler.
- If the tenant requested the broker’s service, the tenant pays—typically 2 months’ cold rent + VAT, though negotiable.
- Commission must be transparent and agreed in writing; deceptive practices (e.g., disguising tenant as the “commissioner”) are illegal.
In short: Always confirm who requested the broker service before agreeing to pay.
3. Pros and Cons of Using a Mietmakler
Pros
Time-saving: In competitive markets like Berlin or Munich, a broker can fast-track your search.
Access to listings: Some properties are only advertised through brokers.
Professional help: They handle negotiations, documentation, and viewings, easing the process.
Cons
Extra cost if you’re the commissioner—especially significant alongside deposits and rental fees.
Potential scams: Some make tenants sign to appear as if they commissioned the broker, forcing them to pay.
Alternative options: Many listings are available on portals like Immobilienscout24 or WG-Gesucht without broker involvement.
4. Tenant Experiences: What Do People Say?
On forums like Reddit, many share their real-life experiences:
- A prospective tenant noted friends paid brokers around €1,000 to secure an apartment quickly—and some saw it as worthwhile.
- Another user shared being wrongly asked for a commission despite the landlord being the one who hired the broker—and advised being cautious.
- In practice, some people never use brokers—especially if they use online listings directly.
These stories illustrate the mix of convenience and caution surrounding Mietmakler.
5. Legal Rights and Pitfalls to Avoid with Mietmakler
- Understand your role: If you approached the broker, you’re responsible for payment. If the landlord did, you’re not.
- Beware of “Vertragserstellungsgebühr” (contract creation fees): Some unscrupulous brokers try to bypass rules with hidden fees—these can be illegal.
- Escrow or viewing deposits are suspicious: Requests for such deposits for viewings are often scams.
- Always require written commission agreements before signing anything—verbal claims don’t hold up if the fee isn’t legally warranted.
6. Alternatives and Smart Strategies for Renters
Here’s how to approach the rental market smartly:
-
Search without brokers using portals like:
-
ImmoScout24
-
WG-Gesucht
-
-
Use Mietmakler when:
-
You’re in a rush
-
Searching from abroad (expats often benefit)
-
-
Negotiate the commission if you’re paying—it can sometimes be reduced.
-
Review contracts and listings closely—check for hidden fees or misleading claims.
-
Consult expat forums or legal advice to avoid unfair practices.
Conclusion
The figure of the Mietmakler is deeply embedded in Germany’s rental market. Since 2015 reforms, commissions are now governed under the principle that whoever orders the service must pay—period. By staying informed, reading documentation carefully, and considering alternatives, tenants can find great apartments in Germany—without being caught out by unexpected fees.
FAQs
1. What does the “Bestellerprinzip” mean?
It means the person who commissions the broker pays the fee—typically the landlord, unless otherwise arranged.
2. How much can a Mietmakler charge?
Up to two months’ cold rent plus VAT, although final rates may vary.
3. Can tenants avoid broker fees?
Yes—by applying directly to ads placed by landlords or opting for listings without broker involvement.
4. Are there scams related to brokers?
Yes. Some brokers try to trick tenants into paying by falsely claiming tenant initiated the contact. Always verify.
5. When might using a broker be worth it?
If you’re short on time, relocating from abroad, or searching in very competitive markets—alternatives may involve waiting much longer.
